Dilemmas: Which boot/shoe should I buy?

I've been eyeing these Frye boots since they first appeared on the Urban Outfitters site last fall.  Now they are on major sale. (Hooray!) Question is, do I get the Ava Button boots or the Adrienne lace-ups (and if those, then in brown or in plum?).  I threw a pair of "fancy" Uggs and Charlotte Ronson's black booties for comparison.  I also like the Miss Sixty black flats and white Via Spiga sandals but probably won't get them.

10 responses
i like the Ava Button boots! they look more versatile and modern than the lace ups. I've been looking at Frye boots recently too (but cant do more shopping this month) yay for shoes :)
The Ava, I love the look!
Hi - I enjoy your posterouses.
The top three are chic.
The others are cludsy and look uncomfortable too which kills any 'chic' signal.
Best,
harropmike
simple is best
Aw man! I wish I'd waited for everyone's comments. I went ahead and bought the plum-colored Frye boots (#3) but everyone seems to like the ava buttons. Wit those I just couldn't decide on a color: black, brown, or gray, and the leather looked kind of wrinkly whereas I wanted it to be really sharp. Maybe I will break down later and get those too =P
I also got these Franco Sartos on impulse because it's really different from my usual style.
All deals to be had on 6pm.com!  They are having a sale on all Frye boots this week only.

love 2 and 3

x

i like #3! it's a good choice. i would have picked those. lace up boots never go out of style. :)
I like #1
Ava. The Adrienne's look like they hit closer to mid-calf, which will make us non-GiseleB folks look like we have shorter legs.
Dang everyone really likes #1 better -____-  Oh well I'll just have to buy them later!