Dilemmas: Which Rafe bag should I get?

I have never bought a handbag for more than... $35, I think, and that was a black Guess mini-bag (what my friend Jane calls an 'armpit bag' because it fits neatly right under your arm like that).  I liked it a lot and it served its purpose well as an all-purpose bag.  

Being of cheap quality though, the handle has been cracking in many spots for a long time, and I think it may be time to graduate from it, and possibly make the leap into 'designer,' or at least real leather, handbags.  As always, I refuse to pay full price and am looking for something that stays within a sane price range.

A few weeks ago, the Gilt Groupe offered a sale on Rafe New York handbags and I was enamored with the designs. Well structured rather than slouchy, with lots of shiny details, buckles, and embellishments.  And an embossed patent-leather crocodile texture I find very hard to resist.  I also like the fact that the designer has a non-conventional background (he's a Filipino immigrant).  I was too chicken to take the plunge back then, but I found that Amazon is selling the bags for... if not the same rock-bottom prices as GG, at least lower than anyone else on the market.

I'm pretty sure I want to get myself one for Christmas.  I just can't decide which one to get--the front-flap messenger bag for $174 (from $475), the medium-sized trapezoidal-looking tote for $183 (from $495), or the large, roomy tote for $228 (from $595.. probably the best deal)?

Thoughts much appreciated.

5 responses
I vote Messenger Bag.
small tote!
roomy tote!
btw, i created a 'good' name for my posterous. incredibleedibles, check us out ;)
If you want one to replace your old hand bag(for shopping and other non-work related activities), I'd go for the medium sized tote, otherwise, the large tote looks very versatile and stylish.
i think yes, it looks beatiful do you have shoes for it:)
very female question isn't it:)