Dilemmas: Never spent more than $35 on a purse...is now the time to start?

I probably need a more grown-up bag.  The one I've been carrying with the cracked handles is, how you say, ghetto.  I've been on the lookout (i.e. gilt.com) for something in the $100 - $300 range that I can use daily, but nothing's really caught my eye, or if it did, then I didn't get to it in time or I was never sure if it was the one.

I feel pretty strongly against the mass-market so-called "luxury" brands (e.g. Coach) and so began poking around etsy.com - clicked "buy," chose the bag category and typed in "leather" as a search.  It returned some 314 pages and I just spent two hours going through about 200 of those pages.  Who knew there were so many talented leather artists?  I like the idea of a) supporting artisans and b) having someting somewhat personalized.  I culled the best of my favorites here.  Yeah, I can't decide.

5 responses
wow. 27 does not look handmade at all. I think that's my favorite. 15 is nice, sophisticated trendy while 23 is boho chic and of the moment. i think those are my picks. although i really like 4 too. the hobo shape is casual but i like the detailing a lot. good luck! i'd love to see what you ended up with. :)
#12. I love the key bling. Etsy is my downfall. I heart Etsy :-D
YES
#4: Classic, clean, neutral, will match most outfits.

#9: Extremely unique, but you'd better really love it. :)

#13: What I said about #9, but it feels a bit more toned down and classic. Boho.

#19: Love the execution of this purse, as long as those knots stay knotted...

#26: My favorite for aesthetics, but not sure how it's organized inside or if it's going to be a big deep hole where you can't find your stuff.

NO:
#12: Not sure if the key closure is ceramic or painted metal, but in either case, it's going to be used so much for securing and closing that it will likely crack or chip. Not worth the back and forth to Etsy vendor for repair.

#18: Bag looks great, but the reality is that you're going to want to kill something after fastening/unfastening those buckles enough times. If they're magnetized faux buckles, you might demagnetize your cards accidentally. Lose-lose.

Be careful with colours - your bag should match with other stuff. I like the classical style (Bree) mostly - but some of your choice really has charm. My favorites: that bag with the key and the white-black one. I like the numbers 11, 12, 16, 18, 19, 20, 27
there are some great ones in the mix! and how brave of you to scour 200 pgs of etsy. i have several favorites. is your future bag in there?