Don't you love how 'inspiration' in the fashion world means wholesale plagiarism?

Behold the 'Drift' mary-jane from BCBGirls.  At a relatively affordable $112, they are a sensible alternative to the much-celebrated and sought-after studded 'Pigalle 100' pumps from Christian Louboutin.  I actually think I like the mary-janes better because the strap makes it so much more practical and wearable, plus I kind of prefer the suede over the leather.  If it weren't for the daunting 4.5" heels (even with a 0.5" platform), I would totally buy them.


I'm just a bit bemused by how much these shoes really 'borrow,' 'steal,' 'reference,' what have you, the original Louboutins.  For an industry that is so obsessed with protecting designs and intellectual property, it seems the line is very fuzzy and muddy indeed.

Here are the originals for your reference.  I think they retail upwards of $900.  And they look very dangerous besides.

Hat tip to A Girl's Guide to Shoes for finding the BCBG pumps first.
13 responses
They're probably a closer knock-off of the mostly-studded Prada fall runway shoe collection: http://www.neimanmarcus.com/store/catalog/templates/P6.jhtml?itemId=cat23170731&parentId=cat14860748&masterId=cat000011
Hmm I guess studs are just the thing this season!  I really like the Prada studded pumps... has a more solid heel and graceful profile dontchathink?
yah love love love the prada pumps -- i think they might be about to go to 40% off @ both barneys and neimans this week with the private sale
many designers knock off other designers so the trend can flow to the masses (and also at a much cheaper price). forever 21 is the epitome of wholesale plagiarism and many fashion houses are fighting back with lawsuits - http://nymag.com/daily/fashion/2009/04/forever_21s_ability_to_copy_de.html http://www.publicknowledge.org/node/948
Louboutin has the red undershoe as its trademark, which BCBG didn't tread upon.
@Maggie and yet don't we all love to shop at F21? =)
@Lee now if they did that, that'd be an instant lawsuit methinks.
Perhaps in an instant, but since Trovato means found, perhaps you'd find yourself in one.
How do I know Louboutin - the shoe museum in Toronto had a great show of his designs.
My only problem with the BCBGirls shoe is the flare of heel at the bottom - it takes away from the overall shape and the studding looks incomplete although it's supposed to be that way. I'm still a lover of the Louboutins!
It's so funny, a bunch of dudes picked these pink studded heels for Endless.com ad banners back in October: http://www.endless.com/Rock-Republic-Womens-Nika-Studded/dp/B002DE5PCY
You know Jena, I'd totally go for those except for the scary-looking heels!
Two totally different shoes in design and style. Those BCBG's look more like Balmain http://taytrong.posterous.com/7809161
Thanks Stephanie for being my 1st subscriber. I used to live at Market/Laguna in 2007 and miss the Bay area sometimes.

@Maggie, this is and will always be true as ideas and decades get recycled. All the studding, shredding, DIY, punk, grunge, fatigue actually started back in 2006 with Junya Watanabe

http://needle-exchange.ca/images/inspiration/junya_watanabe_2006rtw_6.jpg

If you want to know what most designers are going to do the next 1,2,3 seasons, just look at what Rei Kawakubo is doing right now. Her and Watanabe are the most copied designers.

@Tay of course, we Posterous style enthusiasts ought to stick together!  You seem to really like comme des garcons' work... I'm not too familiar with it but it certainly looks interesting.